Friday, February 03, 2006 7:01 PM codingsanity

Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Sitting here watching my international bandwidth slow to nothing, getting timeouts pinging microsoft.com, and am contemplating the wonders of monopolies. Our lovely Telkom has had the following downtimes recently (from what I can sniff out):

Fri 20 Jan 11:45-14:00
Wed 25 Jan 13:00-17:00
Mon 30 Jan 16:08-16:20 - Slowdown on backbone
Tue 31 Jan 12:12-??? & sometime in the evening
Fri 3  Feb 17:30-current

So in 355 hours (from 00:00 Fri 20 Jan to 19:00 Fri 3 Feb), we have had approximately 9h45m of downtime. I'm counting the two times on the 31st as 1 hour each, and not counting the slowdown on the 30th. This equates to 2.7% downtime. Hell, Windows 95 has better uptime than that!

Of course if you try to phone them you get their lovely hold music for ages. I hung on for 8 minutes before giving up in frustration.

I've told my ISP in no uncertain terms that I'm very happy with their service, but the very day that the second national telecoms operator starts offering ADSL to the public, I'm moving. Ideally, I'd like to stay with my ISP, but I will move from Telkom immediately. I know of 3 friends, 5 smallish (<50 employees) companies, and two largeish (50-300 employees) that have the same attitude. Interestingly, those are the only people/companies I've discussed Telkom with, so effectively out of the sample I've polled, 100% will leave Telkom as soon as is practical. That's a whole bunch worse than the rosy 15% customer abandonment Telkom management are bracing their investors for.

[warning: I am not a financial analyst, and this advice should be taken with a BIG grain of salt]

My personal advice to any holders of Telkom shares would be to slowly start reducing their exposure. I personally would aim for a complete divestiture by the end of the year.

Telkom dogged by network problems

Latest ADSL shortage in Gauteng frustrates users

Telkom explains ADSL hitch

Telkom clarifies ADSL outage

All those are articles from one site since the 20th Jan this year. Not bad for two weeks work.

Another 30 minutes has passed, and Telkoms downtime grows to 2.88%.

Update: Missed some downtime they had on the 28th Jan from 20:33 to 21:28. That brings them up to (now) 11h15m of downtime in 355h30m, which is 3.16%.

Comments

# re: Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Saturday, February 04, 2006 5:05 AM by Andre Hartzenberg

I dumped Telkom over a year ago, in favour of Sentech. I got fed up with the never ending ISDN problems. Now, Sentech is a pretty mediocre ISP, but they beat Telkom by a mile. :-)

# re: Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Saturday, February 04, 2006 12:21 PM by matt

In Telkoms defence... (god forbid); that equates to somewhere between 4 and 5 9's of uptime (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uptime)... Which is pretty bloody good. I have heard much worse stories from friends with iBust erm..iBurst.

# re: Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Sunday, February 05, 2006 7:18 PM by Prieur du Plessis

At least you have ADSL to complain about :) On the 2nd of March it will be officially one year exactly since I ordered my ADSL. Needles to say I am still waiting..... Have since given up all hope of getting any kind of internet at home, excluding 3G on my phone, which sets me back R2/pm which makes it impractical for daily use. Since the merger of Verizon and MCI/UUNet, creating Verizon Business last weekish, I have heard some rumours of them adding some substantial bandwidth to the UUNet SA network, added to that the power of Verizon ISP, maybe some good will come out of it for local users. We can only hope.

# re: Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Monday, February 06, 2006 7:49 AM by Trivium DawnWalker

did you know that telkom manager gets R300 off their phone bill each month and the big wigs get free uncapped adsl?

# re: Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Monday, February 06, 2006 9:29 AM by ratty

For more on Telkom, bad prices, inefficiency, SNOs and broadband, see http://www.hellkom.co.za/

# re: Ahh, the wonders of a monopoly

Friday, February 10, 2006 10:22 PM by codingsanity

Matt, keep in mind that that downtime was measured in 2 weeks. If we extrapolate a 3% downtime to the whole year, we get 97% or one nine. Not good. Also, the downtime ended at about 16:30 the next day, which is 23 hours down, and would bring the total in 2 weeks, 1 day to 31.5 hours, or 8.75%, giving 91.25% up, a figure which doesn't even appear in the wikipedia article.