Saturday, June 03, 2006 9:23 AM codingsanity

SADeveloper Article Rankings

I've noticed that neither of my last two articles on sadeveloper have been given any rankings. I went and investigated, and found that no-one has bothered to give any rankings or comments for any articles (there are 4) in the last two months. I don't rate articles because it might be seen as a conflict of interest (you know, dragging another article down to make mine look better). But not everyone in sadeveloper writes articles.

I don't know about the others, but I personally enjoy having feedback. I've heard some complaints in dotnet.org about article quality on sadev. Go have a look at the sadeveloper main page and look at the most recent articles and the most popular. If you don't like anything you see there, rank it down! If you'd like to see more of one kind of article, rank it up! The thing is that when you're thinking of writing an article for a site like sadev, you go and look and see what people like.

The comments you receive on your article influence your future ones. If someone says "I'd prefer more in-depth detail", then you'll keep that in mind when writing your next article. The point is that these rating systems are a sort of feedback look that the readers can use to train the writers into writing what the readers want.

Filed under:

Comments

# re: SADeveloper Article Rankings

Saturday, June 03, 2006 7:55 PM by Senkwe

Personally I think your articles are great. I think the current sadev article format is the problem. There currently isn't much of a distinction between a blog post and an article. I still think CodeProject has it 100% spot on in that most article entries are either lengthy tutorials bearing no resemblance to a blog post, or actual applications that are either useful or educational. With sadev, I find it's far too easy for me to read your article as a blog post, nod in acknowledgmentt...and move on.

So in summary, it's not your fault :-)

# re: SADeveloper Article Rankings

Saturday, June 03, 2006 10:21 PM by codingsanity

But that's the point that I'm trying to make. Whether my articles are worthwhile or not is besides the point. If no-one is going to bother rating the articles, shouldn't we just drop the whole rating system and just show the most recent articles on sadev?

# re: SADeveloper Article Rankings

Monday, June 05, 2006 1:18 PM by MaLio

Hi

We at SADev are always looking to improve the site. If you have any suggestion as how to improve the articles section, I would love to hear, especially whit regard to encouraging ratings.  *sounds almost political*

Also we appreciate article submission, especially good ones, such as those from 'codingsanity' ;-)

MaLio

(comments above noted)